ESG Reporting Practices and Their Role in Driving Circular Economy Innovation and Triple Bottom Line Performance among Philippine Manufacturing Enterprises: A Narrative Literature Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11594/Keywords:
ESG Reporting, Triple Bottom Line, Circular Economy Performance, Narrative Literature ReviewAbstract
The study examines at how Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) reporting is helping mold a more responsible and sustainable future for manufacturing businesses in the Philippines. Today, businesses are no longer judged by profit alone. They are also expected to show how they protect the environment, treat people fairly, and operate with integrity. Utilizing a narrative literature review of studies published from 2015-2025, this research explores how this concept supports circular economy innovation and improves Triple Bottom Line performance, which focuses on people, planet, and profit. The review shows that government regulations, especially the SEC Memorandum Circular No. 4 (2019), greatly increased sustainability reporting among companies. While many firms now comply with reporting requirements, the actual depth of sustainability actions still differs across organizations. Evidence shows that strong ESG practices encourage circular strategies such as reducing waste, reusing materials, and designing products for longer use. These efforts are further supported by national policies like the Extended Producer Responsibility Act of 2022. But, problems remain, including limited data, uneven reporting quality, and resource constraints among smaller firms. In the nutshell, the study emphasizes that meaningful ESG reporting, combined with circular economy practices and responsible leadership can help Philippine manufacturers achieve long-term growth, resilience, and global competitiveness.
Downloads
References
Accounting For Sustainability. (2022). REPORTING INSIGHTS SUSTAIN-ABILITY DATA COLLECTION. Challenge Valida-tion. Https://Www.Accountingforsustainability.Org/En/Knowledge-Hub/Guides/Sustainability-Reporting-Insights-Series.Html
Accuracy. (2026). ESG Reporting For SME: The Essential 3-Step Guide | Accuracy. Expert Editing & Proofreading | Trusted By 10K+ | Accura-cy. Https://Proaccuracy.Com/Blog/Esg-Reporting-Guide-Sme/
Amira Ali M. Omeir, Patricia Empleo, Ma. Belinda S. Mandigma. (2023). Environmental Disclosures of Se-lected Publicly Listed Companies in the Philippines. Review Of Integrative Busi-ness And Economics Research. Https://Buscompress.Com/Uploads/3/4/9/8/34980536/Riber_13-1_15_S23-053_203-221.Pdf
Amit Kumar Srivastava & Shailja Dixit & Akansha Abhi Srivastava. (2022, Febru-ary 2). Criticism Of Triple Bottom Line: TBL (With Special Reference. Economics And Finance Research | IDE-AS/Repec. DOI: 10.1057/S41299-021-00111-X
Andrew Osei Agyemang & Abednego Osei & Maxwell Kongkuah. (2025, February 2). Exploring The ESG‐Circular Economy Nexus in Emerging Markets. Economics And Finance Research | IDE-AS/Repec. Https://Ideas.Repec.Org/A/Bla/Bstrat/V34y2025i5p5901-5924.Html
Antoni. (2025). THE INFLUENCE OF SUSTAIN-ABILITY REPORTING ON INVESTOR DE-CISIONS IN MANUFACTURING COMPA-NIES. International Journal Of Economic Literature (INJOLE).
Bangko Sentral Ng Pilipinas. (2022). The Phil-ippine Sustainable Finance Roadmap. Https://Www.Bsp.Gov.Ph/Regulations/Issuances/2022/CL-2022-011.Pdf
Bayo Manila Inc. (2021). CIRCULAR ECONOMY BUSINESS CASE STUDIES IN SOUTHEAST ASIA. SWITCH-Asia. Https://Www.Switch-Asia.Eu/Site/Assets/Files/4152/Bayo_Final-1.Pdf
Daryl F. Quinco. (2024). Determinants Of Sus-tainability Reporting Among the Filipino Firms. Re-searchgate. DOI:10.5281/Zenodo.10049652#322
DENR. (2023). Implementing Rules And Regu-lations Of Republic Act No. 11898 (DENR Administrative Order No. 2023-02). Unit-ed Nations Environment Pro-gramme. Https://Leap.Unep.Org/En/Countries/Ph/National-Legislation/Implementing-Rules-And-Regulations-Republic-Act-No-11898-Denr
Department Of Environment and Natural Re-sources. (2023). IMPLEMENTING RULES AND REGULATIONS OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 11898. Https://Bir-Cdn.Bir.Gov.Ph/Local/Pdf/RMC%20No.%2028-2023%20Annex%20B.Pdf
Diego Gosmar, Anna Chiara Pallotta, Giovanni Zenezini. (2025). Agentic AI Sustainabil-ity Assessment for Supply Chain Document Insights. Arxiv.Org. Https://Doi.Org/10.48550/Arxiv.2511.07097
Engr. Jose Marie Lim, Dr. Alvin Ang, Frances Michelle Nubla, Sandhel Matugas. (2024). Baseline For Circular Economy in the Philippines: A Data Compilation. Ac-cess De-nied. Https://Www.Undp.Org/Sites/G/Files/Zskgke326/Files/2024-04/Baseline%20for%20Circular%20Econo-my%20in%20the%20Philippines_A%20Data%20Compilation%20-%20V4.Pdf
Eni-Egwu Catherine Odima, Ama, G.A.N, Dibia, N.O, Uche Okoro Orji. (2025, October 11). Impact Of ESG Reporting on Cash Flow Margin of Listed Oil And Gas Firms In Nige-ria. Https://Rsisinternational.Org/Journals/Ijriss/Digital-Library/Volume-9-Issue-9/4422-4435.Pdf
Esmaira G. Gunsayan, Eugenio S. Guhao, Jr. (2021). A Structural Equation Model On Organizational Performance Among Manufacturing Firms In Region XII, Phil-ippines. Re-searchgate. Https://Www.Researchgate.Net/Publication/356814383_A_Structural_Equation_Model_On_Organizational_Perfor-mance_Among_Manufacturing_Firms_In_Region_XII_Philippines
GRI. (2022). SME Sustainability Reporting in ASEAN Consolidated Analysis: Key Drivers, Challenges, Benefits, And Ways Forward. Https://Www.Globalreporting.Org/. Https://Www.Globalreporting.Org/Media/Sycn0ukh/Final-Consolidated-Analysis-4-Case-Study-2.Pdf
Gregorio Rafael P. Bueta, Sonny N. Domingo, And Arvie Joy A. Manejar. (2023). Study On Circular Economy Pathways For Waste Management in the Philippines. Philip-pine Institute For Development Stud-ies. Https://Pidswebs.Pids.Gov.Ph/CDN/Document/Pidsdps2346.Pdf
Helen Kopnina, Engelbert Fellinger, Julius De Jong, Alistair Bowden. (2025). Bridging ESG And The Circular Economy: Advanc-ing Corporate Sustainability Through the Updated R-Hierarchy and Circularity Scoring Model | Visions For Sustainability. SIRIO@Unito.It - Sistema Riviste Open Access. DOI: Https://Doi.Org/10.13135/2384-8677/11829
House Bill No. 2479. (N.D.). An Act Promoting The Transition to a Circular Econo-my. Https://Docs.Congress.Hrep.Online/Legisdocs/Basic_20/HB02479.Pdf
Inquirer.Net. (2024). SEC: 95% Of Listed PH Companies Now Reporting ESG Initia-tives. Https://Business.Inquirer.Net/497350/Sec-95-Of-Listed-Ph-Companies-Now-Reporting-Esg-Initiatives
Jay C. Tolentino, J. C. (2025, March 24). The Road to Circularity: An Introduction To Circular Economy For Msmes. Institute For Small-Scale Indus-tries. Https://Beta.Entrepreneurship.Org.Ph/2025/03/24/The-Road-To-Circularity-An-Introduction-To-Circular-Economy-For-Msmes/
Jonathan P. Binaluyo. (2024). Exploring The Challenges And Opportunities For Sus-tainability Reporting Adoption Among Small and Medium Enterprises: A Case In A Developing Country in Asia. Journal Of Infrastructure, Policy and Development 2024, 8(13), 8736. Https://Doi.Org/10.24294/Jipd8736.
Jose Decena III & Gaudencio G. Abellanosa. (2022). Responsible Leadership, Financial Management Practices, And Green Mar-keting Orientation: A Structural Equation Model on Triple Bottom Line Performance Among Food Manufacturing Industries in Region XII. Re-searchgate. Https://Www.Researchgate.Net/Publication/366214758_Responsible_Leadership_Financial_Management_Practices_And_Green_Marketing_Orientation_A_Structural_Equation_Model_On_Triple_Bot-tom_Line_Performance_Among_Food_Manufacturing_Industries_In_Region_XII
Joy Lynn R. Legaspi, Elyjah Thomas T. Avila, Maha Bianca Charisma C. Castro. (2024). How Do Publicly Listed Companies Report on Sustainability? A Mapping of the Standard/Framework Used by Indus-trial Firms in The Philippines. Interna-tional Journal of Environmental, Sustain-ability and Social Science. DOI: Https://Doi.Org/10.38142/Ijesss.V5i2.236
Julienne Elisha Q. Juan, David Joshua T. Marin, John Raymond D. Reyes, Shaila Kimberly U. Sy,. (2022). The Impact Of Sustainabil-ity Reporting on Corporate Financial Per-formance: A Multilevel Modelling Ap-proach Using Evidence from Publicly Listed Companies In The Philippines. An-imo Reposito-ry. Https://Animorepository.Dlsu.Edu.Ph/Etdb_Finman/44/
Justine Marc Salvacion, Karl Campos. (2024). Transforming Waste In The Phil-ippines: Circular Economy's Impact on Business and Environment. Visitor Anti-Robot Validation. DOI: 10.5937/Jpmnt12-54560
Laurence C. Espino and Eugene Burgos Mutuc. (2024). CSR And Financial Performance of Listed Firms in the Philippines. Pre-prints.Org. Https://Doi.Org/ 10.20944/Preprints202410.0947.V1
Michael Steve Cruz. (2022). Employing Inter-nal Audit System Towards Business Sus-tainability: Evaluating Its Impact on The Triple Bottom Line Perspective in the Manufacturing Industry | Journal Of Busi-ness And Management Studies. Al-Kindi Center For Research And Develop-ment. Https://Doi.Org/10.32996/Jbms.2022.4.3.8
National Economic and Development Authori-ty. (2020). PHILIPPINE ACTION PLAN FOR SUSTAINABLE CONSUMPTION AND PRODUCTION (PAP4SCP). FAOLEX Data-base | Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Na-tions. Https://Faolex.Fao.Org/Docs/Pdf/Phi228020.Pdf
PCX Markets. (2025, November 4). A Compre-hensive Guide to the Philippine EPR Law. Https://Www.Pcxmarkets.Com/Blog-Posts/Comprehensive-Guide-To-The-Philippine-Extended-Producer-Responsibility-Epr-Law
Practicalesg.Com. (2026). Philippines Adopts Mandatory ESG Reporting Standards In Line With IFRS. Https://Practicalesg.Com/2026/01/Philippines-Adopts-Mandatory-Esg-Reporting-Standards-In-Line-With-Ifrs/
Securities And Exchange Commission (SEC). (2019, February 21). Memorandum Circu-lar (MC) No. 4, 2019- Sustainability Re-porting Guidelines for Publicly-Listed Companies (The Guidelines), To Promote Sustainability Reporting and Make It Rel-evant for Philippine Publicly-Listed Com-panies (Plcs). Grant Thornton Philip-pines. Https://Www.Grantthornton.Com.Ph/Alerts-And-Publications/Technical-Alerts/Accounting-Alerts/2019/2019/Sustainability-Reporting-Guidelines-For-Publicly-Listed-Companies/
Securities And Exchange Commission. (N.D.). Sustainability Reporting Guide-lines for Publicly-Listed Companies. SBFN Data Portal | SBFN. Https://Data.Sbfnetwork.Org/Sites/Default/Files/1860_Philippines_Sustainabil-ity_Reporting_Guidelines_For_Publicly_Listed_Companies_2019_SEC.Pdf
Vergil Joseph I. Literal. (2020). Influence Of Sustainable Management Practices, Stra-tegic Orientation and Organizational Cul-ture on Sustainability Performance in Manufacturing FIRMS. IOER International Multidisciplinary Research Journal – Www.Ioer-Imrj.Com. Https://Www.Ioer-Imrj.Com/Wp-Content/Uploads/2020/07/Influence-Of-Sustainable-Management-Practices-Strategic-Orientation-And-Organizational-Culture.Pdf
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Alberlyn Jo Mary L. Alegre
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See the Effect of Open Access).
